Army Pays Trax Legal Fees to Settle AI Bid Evaluation Dispute, Report Says

Army Pays Trax Legal Fees to Settle AI Bid Evaluation Dispute, Report Says

Photo by Petty Officer 3rd Class Avery Tibbets, DVIDS. Illustrative image: A Shield AI contractor speaks to members of the Vietnam media about a V-BAT unmanned aerial system display in the hangar of the U.S. Coast Guard cutter Bertholf in Ho Chi Minh City on Nov. 1, 2026.

By Steven Smith

The Army has paid Trax International's legal fees to settle a dispute over the government's misstatements about an artificial intelligence tool used to evaluate proposals for a White Sands Missile Range support contract, Washington Technology reports. Neither side has disclosed the amount.

Trax's defeat in court is unaffected. The company lost its bid protest at the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, and Washington Technology reports that the settlement does not change that outcome. The contract went to Southwest Range Services, a joint venture of SA-Tech, Amentum and EWA Warrior Services.

What the Army agreed to cover is narrower than the protest itself. According to Washington Technology, the payment is for Trax's expenses in fighting to get AI-generated evaluations of the proposals added to the administrative record of the case. During the litigation, the outlet reports, the Army admitted that it had withheld its use of the AI tool from that record.

The government paid the fees on Nov. 5, Washington Technology reports, but the agreement is not final. Judge Carolyn Lerner still has to approve it and close a show-cause order she wrote in September. That order remains sealed.

Lerner wrote the order to make the government explain itself in court after the Army's account of how it used the tool, known as Fast Track, kept changing, according to the report. The order could have led to sanctions against Justice Department and Army attorneys. Trax and the Army are now both asking the judge to take no action on it.

Two other details in the report bear on that request. Trax's attorney has told the court he believes the government's errors were not deliberate. Government lawyers, in their filings, apologized several times to the judge and to Trax.

How the tool entered the competition is laid out in an earlier Washington Technology report on Lerner's ruling. The government told the court that a procurement analyst had run the proposals through Fast Track to test whether it could be used in future source selections. It said the evaluation board saw only one output, for a third bidder, on a screen, judged it unusable, and that no output entered the contract file or the decision.

That account changed when Lerner ordered Army officials to answer specific questions in supplemental declarations, Washington Technology reported. The analyst then acknowledged for the first time that he had also sent the AI evaluations of the Trax and Southwest Range Services proposals to three people. Two sat on the evaluation board. The third was the contracting officer.

Lerner ordered the AI evaluations into the record. Once they were there, the outlet reported, the board's evaluation of the third bidder turned out to contain passages nearly sentence-for-sentence identical to the AI-generated one.

Trax still lost. It had argued that Fast Track committed several hallucinations that made the Southwest Range Services proposal look superior to its own. Lerner denied the protest in a Sept. 22 ruling because Trax could not identify actual errors in the evaluation that could be traced to the tool, according to Washington Technology.

On the money, Washington Technology describes the award as a $450 million contract for mission support services and does not say whether that figure is a ceiling or an obligated amount. Nextgov/FCW reported, in an article carried by Washington Technology, that roughly $450 million was the size of Southwest Range Services' successful bid.

The same Nextgov/FCW article says the Government Accountability Office denied an earlier Trax protest in May, before the company filed its complaint at the court in late July. It also says the Defense Department has noted in several recent solicitations that it uses AI to assist with bid evaluations.

Several points are not established by these reports. They do not say who built Fast Track or what model it runs on. They do not say whether the Army has used it in any other source selection, or what rules now govern disclosing such use to bidders and to a court. The terms of the settlement beyond the fee payment are not described.

Three developments would show what the case changes. Lerner's decision on the agreement and the show-cause order comes first, and an unsealed order would put its contents on the public record. Any Army statement on whether Fast Track remains in use for source selections would show whether the test continued. The next bid protest that alleges AI use in an evaluation would show whether agencies now place those outputs in the record at the outset.

Leave a Reply